Sudoku Dragon Sudoku Dragon

Sudoku Solver

Download Sudoku Dragon for a free 23 day trial on your PC. It has all the features you need to solve puzzles whether you are new to Sudoku or an expert.

Today's Dragon Tip

Possibility coding
Our unique display grid not only shows you what allocations are possible for each square but also uses color coding to let you see immediately why an allocation is or is not possible.
Read More
Share on Facebook

Share on Google+

Sudoku Strategy

There are only a few strategies that you need to know in order to solve Sudoku puzzles. Please take a look at our Sudoku introduction page for background on terminology and also our theory page. Sudoku Dragon comes with a range of guides that take you through these strategies step by step. You can share your tips and experiences on our strategy message forum. There follows a summary of the techniques you may find useful up to 'advanced' level.

Only choice rule

There may be only one possible choice for a particular Sudoku square. In the simplest case you have a group (row, column or region) that has eight squares allocated leaving only one remaining choice available; so the remaining number must go in that empty square.

Only possible Sudoku square allocationLooking at the second row (B) all the squares except the first one Ba have been allocated so the missing number 4 has no choice but to go in the square Ba. You can use this technique by scanning for 8 allocated squares in all rows, columns or regions.

Sudoku Tutorial For a further in-depth guide guide click here

Single possibility rule

When you look at individual squares you will often find that there is only one possibility left for the square. Note: If there are eight squares solved in the group then this is just the same as the only choice rule. Because of the way that groups intersect you may have a group with more than one unallocated square and yet only one possibility exists for one of the squares. So there is only one possibility for that square, and the number must go there.

Single possibility strategy In this partially solved Sudoku there are quite a few readily solvable squares. Looking at the purple square Da and running through possibilities: 1;2;3;4;5 and 8 that are allocated in column a leaves only 6; 7 and 9 as possibilities. But in row D there is already a 6 and 9 so that leaves 7 as the single possibility for square Da. The single possibility rule can be used to solve all the puzzle squares highlighted in green, so that makes it a very useful technique to have up your sleeve. To use this technique you choose a promising square and mentally run through each number in turn that might go in it, if there is only one number left then that number must go in the square.

Sudoku Tutorial For a further in-depth guide guide click here

Only square rule

Often you will find within a group of Sudoku squares that there is only one place that can take a particular number. For example if a group has seven squares allocated with only two numbers left to allocate it is often the case that an intersecting (or shared) group forces a number to go in one of the squares and not the other one. You are left with an only square within a group for a number to go in. This is different to the 'single possibility' rule where we looked at squares on their own rather than as a group.

Forced allocation of Sudoku square In this case the highlighted column c has seven numbers allocated. The missing numbers are 1 and 3. But you can see that there is already a 3 in row I (square If) so a 3 cannot go in square Ic, the 3 must go in the other square Ac it is the only square in column c where a 3 can be allocated.

You will often find that the same square can be solved by the 'single possibility' rule as well as the 'only square' rule. It doesn't matter which rule you use, as long as the square is solved. Note: Whenever there are eight allocated in a group with only one remaining empty you can assign a symbol by applying either the 'only choice', 'single possibility' or 'only square' rules as all of them come down to the same thing. It is a feature of Sudoku that squares can be solved in several ways using different strategies.

Sudoku Tutorial For a further in-depth guide guide click here

 

Two out of three rule

The next useful solution strategy builds on the Only Square rule. Some Sudoku authors refer to it as 'slicing and slotting'. It is a quick way of solving squares as it can be done in your head by scanning the puzzle grid. It almost always finds a square or two that can be solved. At the heart of the technique is to take groups of three rows and columns in turn, working methodically through the whole grid. First look for all the 1s then all the 2s, 3s etc. all the way through to the 9s. Here's an example of how it works, for more details look at our 2 out of 3 strategy page or download our puzzle solver and take the free guides for this topic.

Two out of Three strategy Look at the top three rows where the 1s are located - they are in row A column e (Ae) and Row C column a (Ca) There is no 1 in row B, it must go in one of the blank squares. Because of the 1 in Ae it can not go in any other of the squares in region Ad that is Bd; Be or Bf. By elimination there is only one place 1 can go in row B and that is in the highlighted square Bi. Using the same logic for the following three rows D; E; F there is again two of them with a 1 in them: squares Eh and Ff. There is a 1 missing from row D and because of the 1 in Eh it can't be in Di, 1 must be assigned to Dc. For the last three rows there are already three 1s Gd; Hb and Ig so there is no 1 left to be allocated.

You can then look at the 2s in these three sets of three rows. In rows A; B; C there are 2s in Ai and Cb so there is a 2 missing in row B, however in this case there are three unallocated squares Bd; Be and Bf so it can't be quickly decided in which one of these the 2 should go. The same happens in rows D; E; F there are two 2s but both Ed and Ef are possible. Finally in G; H; I there are two 2's Gg and Hc and so there is a 2 missing in row I. The existing 2's mean there is only one place it can go - square Id. You can then continue this scan through all rows then all columns in groups of three and then through all the numbers 1 through 9. Whenever you allocate a square this may, in turn, unlock other squares so it is worth restarting the same procedure over for the whole grid.

To download this puzzle and
see it in Sudoku Dragon download Sudoku puzzle click here...

The procedure is to scan rows and columns in groups of three and look to see where if anywhere the number being scanned has been allocated. If you find two out of the three then you know that the missing number can only go in only one of three squares in this row (or column), and more often than not only one of these is possible and must be allocated there. It will find squares that you could also have found using the only choice, only square and single possibility strategies.

When using the Sudoku Dragon software you can use the automatic allocation feature to automatically find and solve squares that can be solved with the 'only choice', 'single possibility' and 'only square' rules, leaving you free to concentrate on solving the harder squares.

Sudoku Tutorial For a further in-depth guide guide click here

Sub-group exclusion rule

More rarely needed in Sudoku, but exceptionally useful is the sub-group exclusion rule. This takes a lot more explanation as instead of 'forcing' a number in a square, it is an application of logic that knocks out possibilities that at first sight looked possible. By excluding one possibility for a square may mean there is only one remaining possibility left, so the square can be safely set to the remaining alternative. Here's an example of the sub-group rule.

Subgroups

A sub-group is a term used to describe three squares in a row or column that intersect a Sudoku region. Every row and column has three sub-groups in the three regions it crosses. In this example the region Aa has been color coded to show the three subgroups it forms with columns a; b and c. The three purple squares are the sub-group intersecting region Aa and column a; the orange squares the sub-group with column b and the green ones the sub-group with column c. The region also has three sub-groups with the rows A; B and C. Every square in the grid belongs to two sub-groups - one for the column it is in and one for the row it is in.

The sub-group exclusion strategy is when you can prove that a number occurs in one of the sub-group squares even though it can't be deduced which of the three sub-group squares it does go in. If you then look beyond that sub-group to the row or column it is in, you can exclude that number from the other intersecting squares. This may not solve a square, but it narrows down the possibilities. A couple of examples follow to explain it.


Our Sudoku Dragon has a free tutorial that explains what is going on step by step.

Subgroup exclusion Sudoku ruleHere is a brief example using the simpler 4x4 puzzle size, so there are only four possibilities to think about instead of nine. Sudoku Dragon has been used with possibilities enabled and exclusions switched on so that the grid directly shows the squares where the exclusion rule comes into play.

First look at column d, you'll see that the 1 must go in Cd and that's the only place it can go in the region Cc. Applying the subgroup rule for the subgroup shared between column d and region Cc (highlighted in blue) means that 1 can only occur in this blue subgroup and can not go in any other square in the region, so a 1 can not go in squares Cc or Dc, so that is why 1 is shown as with a 'not possible' darker background by the puzzle solver. Moreover because Dc could only take a 1 or 4 it's now certain that 4 must go here.

The other subgroup we could have used in this Sudoku puzzle example is the one shared between column a and region Cb (highlighted in red). Here we can tell that 4 must be allocated in Ca as that is the only place in column a that can take it. So using the subgroup rule 4 can not go in either Cb or Db, and so we can safely assign 1 to Db. Note: 4x4 Sudoku examples do not really show the full power of the rule as simpler rules could have been used to solve these squares.

Subgroup exclusion Sudoku ruleScaling up to a regular 9x9 Sudoku example, the subgroup exclusion happens in the central region Dd. It is the sub-group of the central region with the highlighted row F that is of interest. Look at the squares in row F that a '5' can go, it can't go in Fa (because of Aa) nor in Fh (because of Dh) nor in Fi (because of Bi). That only leaves Fd and Ff both of which occur as a shared sub-group with the central region Dd. The subgroup exclusion rule requires that a '5' can not go in the remaining shared squares in that region highlighted in red: Ed or Ef.

Sudoku Tutorial For a further in-depth guide guide click here

Hidden Twin exclusion rule

You may find you need to use the twin (or triplet) exclusion rules in order to solve more challenging Sudoku puzzles. It is the strategy to use when simpler strategies have been applied and you are still stuck. In essence it is all about spotting matching patterns of possibilities in a group (row, column or region). Spotting these groups takes time and it is difficult to keep track of these in your head, so this is where you need pencil and paper (or the Sudoku Dragon puzzle solver).

If you have two or more unallocated squares in a region and there are two numbers that can only go in the same two squares and no others in that group you have a twin. This does not directly help to allocate squares as the number could go in either of them. However, if the two squares have another possible number then this number can be safely eliminated as an option. It is excluded because of the presence of the hidden twin in the group. Studying an example is the best way to get your mind around this rule.

Hidden Twin exclusion Sudoku rule Look at this 4x4 grid. There are a lot of easier squares that could be filled in, but we've ignored them as we are illustrating the hidden twin rule. Look at the green region Aa, none of the squares have yet been allocated. Both 2 and 3 must go somewhere in the region but it turns out that there are only two possible squares. So we have detected a twin {2,3} in squares Aa and Ba. Because of this twin the possibility of a 1 in square Aa can be knocked out. Also square Ba looked like it might be a 4 but this too can be excluded due to the same {2, 3} twin. How does this work? There are only two ways that the twin of {2, 3} can be allocated, either the 2 in Aa and 3 in Ba or alternatively 3 in Aa and 2 in Ba. These are the only two ways that {2, 3} can be set in this region. So in both of the two possible ways the squares Aa and Ba are allocated. This does not allow the possibility of the 1 being allocated in Aa or the 4 being allocated in Ba - they must be allocated somewhere elsewhere in the group. Whenever there are the same number of possibilities restricted to the same number of squares this logic can be applied. [See the theory page for further explanation.] Note: The rule for twins extends to triplets too. If you find that three symbols have only three shared possible squares in a group (row, column or region) then all other possibilities in these three squares can be discounted. And on it goes, the same sort of rule applies to quadruplets, quintuplets etc. but these are very rarely found in real Sudoku puzzles.

Our Sudoku Dragon software has a free tutorial that explains twins in more detail with an animated guide.

This rule is named the hidden twin rule as the twins are only found by considering other squares in the group. Discovering the twins is the challenge.

Sudoku Tutorial For a further in-depth guide guide click here

Naked Twin exclusion rule

Naked exclusion Sudoku rule Another way to exclude possibilities in a group is with the naked twins . In this case the twin squares are evident on their own (and so they are termed 'naked' to distinguish them from the previous 'hidden' case) and these are used to exclude possibilities in other squares in the same group. Here's how it works.

This 4x4 Sudoku has the region Ca highlighted in green. The 'naked twins' are located in Ca and Cb with possibilities {2, 3}. Because these two squares have no other possibilities we can deduce that a 2 must go in Ca and 3 in Cb or else 3 in Ca and 2 in Cb, there are no other alternatives for these two squares. So looking at square Da the naked twin rule excludes 2 from occurring here (because we have just shown that region Ca must have a 2 in either Ca or Cb). As Da is now left with one possibility a 1 can be safely allocated there. For the same reason the naked twin also eliminates 2 from square Cc and a 4 must go there.

Sudoku Tutorial For a further in-depth guide guide click here

General permutation rule

The two 'twin' rules are particular examples of the general Sudoku logic. It is all down to permutations. Each Sudoku group is a permutation of the numbers 1 to 9 (for a 9x9 grid). If you can identify a group within this permutation that is restricted to the same number of squares then you have a Sudoku permutation rule. Note: In fact the 'only square'; 'single possibility' and 'only choice' are just special cases of this general rule - only one square is involved in this case. This general rule has more exotic applications.

The twin, triplet, quadruplet rules just reflect different number of possibilities (2,3,4...). However there are also chains. A chain can take in any number of squares, for example if three squares in a group allow just the possibilities {1,7}; {4,7} and {1,4} there is a closed chain of three symbols {1,4,7} which is neither a twin nor a triplet. Detecting this chain lets you safely exclude a possible 1, 4 and 7 elsewhere in the same group. So the logic applies equally for chains as it does for twins, there are 'naked chains' and 'hidden chains'.


X-Wing and Swordfish

One of the more complex Sudoku strategies is the 'X-Wing' and its cousin the 'Swordfish'. These rules are useful for solving the really difficult Sudoku puzzles when all else has been tried and failed.

In looking for twins and permutations we restricted ourselves to looking at possibilities within a single group. The shared sub-group rule is the simplest example of a rule where two groups are looked at to eliminate possibilities. The X-Wing requires looking at multiple groups as well. A better name for this strategy might be 'Box' as you are looking for four squares forming the corners of a box. These squares must be the only permitted squares for that number in that row (or column) for one particular symbol. This box arrangement forms a two dimensional link. If the symbol spotted occurs in the top left corner of the box it must then also occur in the bottom right corner of the box. The only other alternative is that it occurs in the top right corner in which case it must then occur in the bottom left corner. No other option is possible for these four squares and this number. Just as with the sub-group rule, this can knock out possibilities somewhere else in the Sudoku grid.

X-Wing Sudoku ruleHere's an example (and good X-Wings are hard to find). Sudoku Dragon has highlighted all the squares where a 4 is allocated or looks like it can be allocated. The rows C and G are crucial. They both have only two squares that can take a 4: Ca, Cf, Ga and Gf - highlighted in blue - this is the vital starting point. Moreover these 4s form the corners of a rectangular box (highlighted in orange). How is this useful? Well, because there must the 4 in column a must either go in Ca or Ga and nowhere else in that column. Similarly in column f (the 4 must be in either Cf or Gf and so we can exclude all the other 4s from these two columns. So all the yellow highlighted squares Aa, Ba, Bf and Ha can have the possibility of 4 safely discounted. If you are lucky then eliminating the 4s will mean you can allocate one of these excluded squares or at least a square in the same group as them. Note: The term X-Wing is probably derived from the name of Star Wars fighter which had an X shaped cross-section.

To download this puzzle and
see it in Sudoku Dragon download Sudoku puzzle click here...
Sudoku Tutorial For a further in-depth guide guide click here

 

Swordfish Sudoku rule Believe it or not the complexity does not end at the X-Wing, the Swordfish is a further refinement of the X-Wing. Instead of four squares forming a box of possible allocations the Swordfish rule uses six squares. In the example puzzle there are not just two pairs of squares for 9 but three pairs: in columns b; e and h. These squares are highlighted in blue/purple color. They are linked by rows to form a box with an extension 'sword' jutting out on one side : hence the term Swordfish. The other squares forming the swordfish are highlighted in orange and yellow. Because all these three columns have coinciding end squares the rule applies again. Any 9s that we find in rows that link the columns can be safely excluded because we know that a 9 must occur in one of the two highlighted squares in that row; they can't be allocated elsewhere. These excluded squares are highlighted in yellow (Fc; Gf and Fg).

Of course, the Swordfish is not the end of the matter we can extend the logic to four interlinking pairs of possibilities and then five etc.. You'll feel a real sense of achievement if you locate a Swordfish and use it to solve a Sudoku puzzle.

To download this puzzle and
see it in Sudoku Dragon download Sudoku puzzle click here...
Sudoku Tutorial For a further in-depth guide guide click here

More advanced strategies

Further complex strategies are available for fiendishly difficult puzzles. They require a lot more thought and analysis to learn about and use correctly. The techniques include the X-Y Wing or Hook and powerful Alternate Pair , they are explained in full on our separate Advanced Strategy page.

Backtracking or Trial and Error

When all else fails, there is one technique that is guaranteed to always work, indeed you can solve any Sudoku puzzle just using just this one strategy alone. You just work logically through all the possible alternatives in every square until you find allocations that work out. Because there are so many alternatives (billions) you won't want to use it too often. You start with a square and one number from the available possibilities. This is a completely different type of strategy as it uses 'brute force' rather than 'logic'. It is the most contentious Sudoku solving technique and so we have a full description of it with examples on our separate Guessing page.

Have you mastered all the strategies for solving Sudoku? Our strategy page gives an introduction to all the main tactics for solving a Sudoku puzzle. We have separate pages on Trial and error as well as Advanced Strategies.. Read more...

See also
Sudoku Strategy Some of the more complex puzzle solving strategies explained.
Sudoku Solution Hints Good introduction to the various strategies for solving puzzles including X-Wing; XY-Wing.
Solving Sudoku Detailed step by step solution of Sudoku puzzles.

contributeAny comments on this page? Click here to contribute

Copyright © 2005-2014 Sudoku Dragon